Manitoba news: Shoal Lake 39 First Nation has taken its $2 billion water fight to a national television audience, with APTN Investigates airing “Troubled Waters” on Saturday, November 21, as its long running court case against the City of Winnipeg and Ontario moves forward.
By Maplestime Manitoba Desk | Winnipeg, Manitoba | November 22, 2026
Sources: APTN News, APTN Investigates, Falconers LLP | Last updated: November 22, 2026
Quick Answer: Shoal Lake 39 First Nation is suing Winnipeg and Ontario for $2 billion, saying its community has paid the price for the city taking Shoal Lake water since 1913. An APTN Investigates episode that aired November 21 tells the story from the community’s side as the case moves forward in Ontario Superior Court.
Key Takeaways
- APTN Investigates episode “Troubled Waters” aired Saturday, November 21, 2026, with reporter Christopher Read travelling to Shoal Lake 39 First Nation (Iskatewizaagegan No. 39 Independent First Nation) in Manitoba.
- The First Nation is suing the City of Winnipeg and Ontario for $2 billion, alleging its home and way of life have paid the price for Winnipeg taking Shoal Lake water.
- The claim began at $500 million and was raised to $2.0 billion. Ontario Superior Court Justice Perell allowed the amended claim on April 12, 2024 (2024 ONSC 2163).
- In 1913, Ontario granted Winnipeg permission to take water from Shoal Lake by Order in Council. Shoal Lake remains Winnipeg’s sole water source.
- In 2026 the case advanced with witness examinations April 20 to 24, an International Joint Commission visit on May 5, and an addendum to the historical report served June 1.
What Is Shoal Lake 39 Asking the Court to Do?
The claim, filed in Ontario Superior Court under file CV-20-00644545-0000, seeks $2 billion from Winnipeg and Ontario. The First Nation, represented by Falconers LLP and led by Chief Gerald Lewis, argues that more than a century of the city drawing its drinking water from Shoal Lake has come at the community’s expense. The episode puts the human cost front and centre: resources that should go to children are being spent on the legal fight instead, and a lawyer in the program describes Winnipeg as waging “a war of attrition.” A community member in the APTN trailer put it plainly: “Their water story has never ever been told from our perspective.” For decades, this story has been told as a Winnipeg engineering success, the aqueduct that brought clean water to a growing city. “Troubled Waters” tells it from the shore of the lake itself.
How Did Winnipeg Come to Take Shoal Lake Water?
The roots of the dispute go back to 1913, when Ontario granted Winnipeg permission to take water from Shoal Lake by Order in Council. The aqueduct that followed has carried Shoal Lake water to Winnipeg ever since, and Shoal Lake remains the city’s sole water source today. The claim started at $500 million before being raised to $2 billion, and Justice Perell allowed the amended claim in April 2024.

What Has Moved in the Case in 2026?
The case has kept moving this year. Witness examinations ran April 20 to 24, 2026, putting testimony on the record. Then, on May 5, 2026, the International Joint Commission visited the community, only its second visit to Shoal Lake and its first to Iskatewizaagegan No. 39 Independent First Nation. An addendum to the historical report was served June 1, 2026. Each step adds to the court record, and each step costs the community time and money that could otherwise go to its children.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is Shoal Lake 39 claiming in its lawsuit?
Shoal Lake 39 is claiming $2 billion from the City of Winnipeg and Ontario. The claim began at $500 million and was raised to $2.0 billion, with Justice Perell allowing the amended claim on April 12, 2024.
When did Winnipeg start taking water from Shoal Lake?
Ontario granted Winnipeg permission to take water from Shoal Lake by Order in Council in 1913. Shoal Lake remains Winnipeg’s sole water source today.
Where can I watch the APTN episode about Shoal Lake 39?
It aired Saturday, November 21, 2026, and APTN News has posted video from it on its official YouTube channel.
Maplestime will provide updates from the Shoal Lake 39 water case as announcements are made.
Have a tip about the Shoal Lake 39 water case? Email [email protected]
Have a correction? Email [email protected]
Do you think Winnipeg owes Shoal Lake 39 for a century of its water, or is a $2 billion claim too much for a deal made in 1913? Tell us in the comments. And share this with every Canadian following First Nations water rights and the Winnipeg aqueduct this weekend.
Enjoying Maplestime? Support independent Canadian journalism — no paywall, no corporate owners.







