Manitoba municipal politics: The Yellowhead mayor recount is now a court order, after a judge told election officials to go back and count again in a race decided by a single vote.
By Maplestime Manitoba Desk | Manitoba | November 18, 2026
Sources: Winnipeg Speaker, Brandon Sun, The North | Last updated: November 18, 2026
Quick Answer: The Yellowhead mayor recount was ordered by a judge in the race for mayor of the R.M. of Yellowhead, decided by one vote on October 28. Incumbent Merv Starzyk beat challenger Jim Garlick 376 to 375, and Garlick asked a Brandon court for a recount, citing 13 rejected ballots. The recount must be held within two weeks.
Key Takeaways
- The Yellowhead mayor recount was ordered by a judge after the October 28 election ended 376 to 375 for incumbent Merv Starzyk over challenger Jim Garlick.
- Garlick asked a Brandon court for a judicial recount, citing 13 rejected ballots, which is 13 times the one vote margin.
- Garlick is also calling for automatic recounts when the top two candidates are within 10 votes of each other.
- Five other Manitoba municipalities had winners decided by fewer than 10 votes in the October 28 elections.
- Under Manitoba law, a judge who grants a requested recount must hold it within two weeks.
What the Yellowhead mayor recount could change
One vote. That is the whole story in Yellowhead, and it is why a judge has now stepped in. Incumbent Merv Starzyk beat challenger Jim Garlick 376 to 375 in the October 28 municipal election, and Garlick asked a Brandon court for a judicial recount, citing 13 rejected ballots.
Thirteen rejected ballots in a race decided by one vote is not a footnote. It is the case. If even one of those ballots was wrongly rejected, the result could flip. If several were, the margin could move the other way entirely. That is exactly what a judicial recount is built to settle, and CTV News reported on November 16 that a judge has now ordered one.
The Brandon Sun reported the original challenge on November 5, under the plain headline that a one vote victory was being challenged in the Yellowhead election. The judge’s order is the fresh development, and it turns a local dispute into a test of how Manitoba handles elections this close.

Why this is bigger than one small town
Yellowhead is not the only close race from October 28. Five other Manitoba municipalities had winners decided by fewer than 10 votes, and at least one other challenger is already in court. Lewis Weiss lost the La Broquerie reeve race by 9 votes and also sought a recount after difficulty monitoring ballot boxes. A hearing was held November 10, and a judge was still deciding as of November 16.
Garlick wants the rules changed, not just his own race recounted. He is calling for automatic recounts when the top two candidates are within 10 votes of each other, so a challenger does not have to go to court to get a second count in a race this tight.
Municipal Relations Minister Glen Simard said the province will take a serious look at automatic recounts if towns request them. Prof. Christopher Adams of the University of Manitoba called very close recounts “common sense”, while Prof. Aaron Moore warned about the cost. That is the real debate now: how much certainty is a close election worth, and who pays for it.
Related: CUPE Backs Gillingham for Re-election as Winnipeg Mayoral Race Tightens
What happens next in Yellowhead
Under Manitoba law, a judge who grants a requested recount must hold it within two weeks. That puts a firm clock on the process, and Yellowhead should have a final answer soon. The recount will recheck the ballots, including the question of the 13 rejected ones, and either confirm Starzyk as mayor or hand the race to Garlick.
Either way, the lesson is already clear. In a race this close, every ballot matters, and every rejected ballot needs a clear reason behind it. Voters in Yellowhead turned out and split almost exactly down the middle. They deserve a result they can trust, and a recount is the honest way to get one.
Frequently asked questions
What was the result in the Yellowhead mayor race?
Incumbent Merv Starzyk beat challenger Jim Garlick 376 to 375 in the October 28, 2026 municipal election, a margin of one vote.
Why was a recount ordered?
Garlick asked a Brandon court for a judicial recount, citing 13 rejected ballots. A judge ordered the recount, as reported by CTV News on November 16, 2026.
When must the recount happen?
Under Manitoba law, a judge who grants a requested recount must hold it within two weeks.
Maplestime will provide updates from the Yellowhead mayor recount as announcements are made.
Have a tip about the Yellowhead mayor recount? Email [email protected]
Have a correction? Email [email protected]
Should every Manitoba race decided by fewer than 10 votes get an automatic recount, or is going to court the right check on a one vote result? Tell us in the comments. And share this with every Manitoban who believes a single vote should never be left in doubt.
Enjoying Maplestime? Support independent Canadian journalism — no paywall, no corporate owners.








