Canadian business news: Canadian Etsy Sellers are shutting their shops weeks before the busiest selling season of the year, and they say Etsy’s new AI training terms left them no choice. The updated terms, published October 26 and taking effect December 16, let Etsy and its partners use sellers’ work to train artificial intelligence.
By Maplestime Business Desk | Toronto, Ontario | November 22, 2026
Sources: CBC News, DesignTAXI, Cybernews | Last updated: November 22, 2026
Quick Answer: Canadian Etsy Sellers are closing their shops because Etsy’s updated terms of use, effective December 16, allow Etsy, its third party partners and vendors to use sellers’ content to develop, train, test and improve AI and machine learning technologies. With no opt out toggle in account settings, sellers who object must email Etsy’s data protection officer or leave the platform.
Key Takeaways
- Etsy’s terms, published October 26, take effect December 16 and allow sellers’ content to train AI and machine learning technologies.
- Canadian Etsy Sellers in Vancouver, Ottawa and Halifax are pulling products or closing shops weeks before the holidays.
- There is no opt out toggle. Sellers who object must email Etsy’s data protection officer, and some say they were told to close their accounts.
- Etsy says sellers’ creative work belongs to them. On November 20 it told the New York Times it would revise the policy.
What Changed in Etsy’s Terms?
The new wording is blunt. Etsy’s updated terms say the company, its third party partners and vendors can use sellers’ content to “develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.” That covers the photos, descriptions and designs sellers upload to run their shops.
A separate October update also tightened rules on misleading AI generated listing images and AI generated guides such as patterns and recipes. The same update tightened rules on misleading AI generated listing images and AI generated guides such as patterns and recipes. The new training clause arrived at the same time, and it is the clause sellers are objecting to.
Why Are Canadian Etsy Sellers Closing Their Shops?
For Canadian Etsy Sellers, the timing is what stings most. The holiday season is when small makers earn a large share of their yearly income, and the new terms force them to choose between that income and the platform. Sellers say they are “being forced” to make exactly that choice.
Tsuki Matsuba of Vancouver, B.C., is pulling her custom stationery products. “It felt like a kick in the teeth,” she said. Ottawa artist Tina Nawrocki wrote on X that she is “closing down” her Etsy shop over the company’s “new predatory AI practices.” Halifax based artist The Calendork removed all artwork from its shop.
The departures reach beyond Canada. Cognitive Surplus, run by Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus, left Etsy after 13 years. Illustrator Aaron Millard is deleting his shop after nearly a decade, and War and Peas closed its shop as well. The total number of departures is unknown.
Related: Tariffs Upend Manitoba Holiday Season as Winnipeg Shops Raise Prices

What Does Etsy Say?
Etsy insists sellers are misreading the policy. James Ossman, the company’s head of customer operations, said respecting sellers’ work is “central” to how Etsy runs its business, that sellers’ “creative work belongs to them,” and that Etsy does not use that work to train “AI models designed to copy their original work or replace their creativity.”
Etsy says the content is used for fraud detection, product discovery and improving listings. But that has not settled the argument for Canadian Etsy Sellers, because the terms themselves speak of developing and training AI, and there is no way to say no inside the platform. On Friday, November 20, Etsy told the New York Times it would revise the policy and share new wording directly with sellers.
What Happens Next?
The revised wording has not been published yet, and the December 16 effective date is less than a month away. If the new wording gives Canadian Etsy Sellers a real choice, some may come back. If it only softens the language while keeping the training rights, the departures are likely to continue. Etsy grew because buyers trusted that a listing came from a real person’s hands, and when those makers walk away before Christmas, the platform has a problem no policy rewrite can paper over.
Frequently Asked Questions
When do Etsy’s new AI training terms take effect?
December 16, 2026. The updated terms were published October 26 and give Etsy, its partners and vendors the right to use sellers’ content to train AI and machine learning technologies.
Can Etsy sellers opt out of AI training?
There is no opt out toggle in account settings. Canadian Etsy Sellers who object must email Etsy’s data protection officer, and some say they were advised to close their accounts.
What has Etsy said about revising the policy?
On Friday, November 20, Etsy told the New York Times it would revise the policy and share new wording directly with sellers. It also says it does not train AI models designed to copy sellers’ original work.
Maplestime will provide updates from Etsy and Canadian sellers as announcements are made.
Have a tip about Etsy and Canadian sellers? Email [email protected]
Have a correction? Email [email protected]
Do you think Etsy should let sellers opt out of AI training with one click, or is closing your shop the only honest answer? Tell us in the comments and share this with every Canadian who buys handmade this Christmas.
Enjoying Maplestime? Support independent Canadian journalism — no paywall, no corporate owners.








