Manitoba justice news: the Manitoba government has brought back a program that lets people work off court fines they cannot afford to pay, weeks after quietly shutting it down, and only after questions from CBC News put the decision in the spotlight.
By Maplestime Winnipeg Desk | Winnipeg, Manitoba | November 22, 2026
Sources: CBC News | Last updated: November 22, 2026
Key Takeaways
- Manitoba has reinstated the fine option program, which lets people do community service to earn credit toward court fines they cannot afford to pay.
- The program stopped taking new registrations on October 1 and was consolidated on October 31, with no public announcement.
- Justice Minister Matt Wiebe first blamed low participation, then reversed course after CBC News asked questions, saying Manitobans deserve fair and accessible justice regardless of financial standing.
- Legal Aid Manitoba called ending the program a very short sighted decision, warning it could push vulnerable people toward jail for unpaid fines.
- No date or next step has been announced for changes to make the program easier to use.
What the Fine Option Program Does
The fine option program gives people who have been fined a choice: do supervised community service and earn credit against the money owed, instead of paying cash they do not have. It is aimed at people who could not otherwise afford to pay their court fines. The program dates back to 1983, when Manitoba first let people fined for minor offences work off what they owed through supervised community service instead of going to jail.

How the Program Was Ended, Quietly
The shutdown happened without a public announcement. The program stopped accepting new registrations as of October 1, and it was consolidated on October 31, according to a provincial spokesperson. On November 13, Justice Minister Matt Wiebe said in an emailed statement that the decision to end it followed several years of low participation and underutilization, and that the province was looking at options on how to make the program more accessible and effective. Then, in a follow-up statement on Thursday, November 19, less than a week later and after CBC News posed questions about the program’s end, Wiebe said the province had decided to reinstate it after evaluating the fine options program and weighing other possibilities. That statement said Manitobans deserve fair and accessible justice, regardless of factors like financial standing.
Why Critics Say the Cut Mattered
Critics warned that removing the program could have immediate and far reaching consequences for some of the province’s most vulnerable people, including incarceration for unpaid fines, garnished wages or tax returns, and being unable to eventually apply for a pardon. Peter Kingsley, executive director of Legal Aid Manitoba, said that even if the program was used by only a small number of people, it is an important option, and removing it would add more challenges for people who are already struggling. He called the decision a very short sighted decision before the province changed course, and said it was sad to take away an opportunity for people to make good on a mistake and improve themselves.
Quinn Saretsky, who has spent years working with people involved in the justice system, was surprised to hear the program had been shut down without any notice. In past work with people at organizations such as the Elizabeth Fry Society of Manitoba, she said working off fines in the community helped people make connections and build skills that could help them later, and stopped them from potentially having to commit more crimes, like theft, to pay what they owed. She is now executive director of Nii Gaanii Asin, a pilot legal clinic that writes Gladue, or Indigenous background, reports. She said of people who valued the program that they showed up and they were consistent, and that it helped build connections and gave an opportunity to people who would not otherwise have it. She was happy to see the program reinstated.
The Barriers Behind the Low Numbers
Saretsky also questioned whether the uptake numbers used to justify scrapping the program reflected the barriers that keep people from taking part, such as child care obligations, transportation, disabilities, and addictions. Government numbers do not necessarily translate to what they mean in practice, she said in substance, and looking more closely at barriers, rather than cutting a program completely, is really important.
What Happens Next
No future date, deadline, meeting, or specific next step has been stated. The province’s position is that the program has been reinstated, and its earlier statement said it was looking at options to make the program more accessible and effective. What those options are, and when they will arrive, has not been announced.
Maplestime will provide updates from the Manitoba fine option program as announcements are made.
Have a tip about the Manitoba fine option program? Email [email protected].
Have a correction? Email [email protected].
Do you think a program used by only a small number of people is still worth keeping when it keeps the poorest Manitobans out of jail, or was the province right to look at the numbers first? Tell us in the comments. And share this with every Manitoban who believes justice should not depend on your bank balance.
Enjoying Maplestime? Support independent Canadian journalism — no paywall, no corporate owners.







