Manitoba aviation news: the floatplane that killed four people from St. Theresa Point First Nation in September 2025 took off with its centre of gravity past the safe limit, and two jerrycans of gasoline were riding in the cabin, the Transportation Safety Board says in a report released Thursday.
By Maplestime Manitoba Desk | Winnipeg, Manitoba | November 19, 2026
Sources: Transportation Safety Board of Canada, CBC News, CTV News Winnipeg | Last updated: November 19, 2026

Key Takeaways
- The Transportation Safety Board released report A25C0103 on Thursday, November 19, 2026, into the September 13, 2025 crash at Makepeace Lake.
- Four passengers from St. Theresa Point First Nation died. The 20 year old pilot survived with serious injuries.
- The 1959 De Havilland Beaver floatplane took off with its centre of gravity about 7.6 centimetres past the rear limit.
- Two jerrycans of gasoline in the cabin were allowed under the rules but may have fed the fire after the crash.
- The plane carried no flight data recorder or cockpit voice recorder, and the safety board says Transport Canada has stalled on requiring them.
What Happened on September 13, 2025
The plane, a single engine 1959 De Havilland Canada Beaver on floats, registration C-FDPW, was flying for MHA Enterprises Ltd. out of St. Theresa Point, about 40 kilometres north of Makepeace Lake, on a hunting trip. It was the third flight of the day. The pilot made two attempts to take off and was told to turn back to the dock both times by a passenger who had anxiety about flying. The flight was called off for the day. Hours later the passengers called back and asked to try again. The plane took off at about 6:30 p.m. into clear skies and calm weather, flew smoothly toward the lake, then flew about 600 metres along the north shore instead of landing on the water. It plunged into the forest and burst into flames. The emergency locator transmitter activated. The Joint Rescue Coordination Centre in Trenton was notified at 6:39 p.m. The pilot phone crash detection alert reached Northern911 at 6:40 p.m. Island Lake RCMP arrived at 9:23 p.m. and found the seriously injured pilot 150 metres from the wreckage. Search and rescue technicians arrived at 11:07 p.m. The pilot was flown by helicopter to Island Lake Airport, then by aircraft to a hospital in Winnipeg.
The Weight and Balance Problem
The report says the plane weighed about 5,274 pounds at takeoff, below the 5,370 pound maximum. The problem was balance, not total weight. The centre of gravity sat at 109.2 inches, which is 3.1 inches past the rear limit of 106.1 inches. CBC and The Canadian Press put that gap at about 7.6 centimetres. Weight sitting further back can improve fuel efficiency, but it makes a plane less stable and overly responsive at the controls, and most critically it can make stall recovery difficult or even impossible. The operator had noticed the calculated centre of gravity was usually outside the aft limit. It believed the empty centre of gravity calculation was inaccurate, but it took no steps to confirm that. The records that could have settled the question were destroyed in the fire. The pilot held a commercial licence with 1,910 hours of flying, including about 140 hours on the Beaver, and a valid Category 1 medical. The report rules out fatigue and medical issues. The weather was suitable for visual flight and was not considered a factor.
Fuel in the Cabin
Two jerrycans filled with gasoline were in the cabin, along with camp supplies that included rifles. Carrying them was allowed under the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations and the operator dangerous goods manual. The report says the fuel could have significantly increased the size and intensity of the fire after the crash. The main fuel tanks sit directly under the passenger cabin floor. MHA Enterprises did not immediately respond to a request for comment, according to CBC and The Canadian Press.
No Recorder on Board
The plane carried no flight data recorder or cockpit voice recorder, and it was not required to have either. That gap hampered the investigation. The safety board recommended back in 2018 that Transport Canada require lightweight recording systems for commercial operators flying light planes. Transport Canada removed that work from its forward regulatory plan in December 2024, with no work before 2028 at the earliest, and in December 2025 said it agreed in principle but would reassess priorities. The board says it is unlikely any requirement will exist before 2030. It calls the response unsatisfactory and has assigned the recommendation dormant status.
What the Safety Board Wants Changed
The report carries two safety messages. Owners and operators must make an accurate weight and balance report available to pilots before dispatch. Pilots must remain aware that loading outside centre of gravity limits can change how a plane handles in ways they do not expect, and that can result in loss of control. Transport Canada did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Related: Ottawa Delays Nutrition North Reform Again as Milk Hits $10.99 in St. Theresa Point
Maplestime will provide updates from the St. Theresa Point plane crash report as announcements are made.
Have a tip about this crash or northern Manitoba aviation? Email [email protected]
Have a correction? Email [email protected]
Should small northern carriers be forced to fit flight recorders, or is that an unfair burden on the lifeline flights remote communities depend on? Tell us in the comments. And share this with every Manitoban who flies north.
Enjoying Maplestime? Support independent Canadian journalism — no paywall, no corporate owners.







